I’ve read a ton of reviews of Ben Affleck’s new film, Argo, since posting mine a few days ago,
and while most are rather positive, I’ve noticed a trend in reviews, especially
among older-aged critics.
Many say despite the fact that they like Argo, they find themselves unable to
fully appreciate it because they already know the story’s ending. This is an
age-old movie discussion: Can you enjoy a film that you already know the ending
to? My simple answer: of course you can.
So, a list. Here are 10 great films based on true stories whose
endings are of common knowledge. A few notes: this list is true story specific.
Discussing the merits of seeing a movie (say, like The Sixth Sense) that you unwilling know the ending to is an
entirely different argument. Lastly, by assuming most know the endings to the
stories the following films depict, I’m admittedly being a tad presumptuous
with this list. If you don’t know what happened to Clyde Barrow and Bonnie
Parker, or have never heard of Watergate, then feel free to pass over the films
you don’t want spoiled.
Bonnie and Clyde
(1967)
Most know that famed bank robbing lovers Clyde Barrow
and Bonnie Parker were gruesomely mowed down by several police officers. So,
how did director Arthur Penn opt to show you something you weren’t expecting?
By… showing you something you weren’t expecting. He shot their demise in
tedious slow motion, in full light, with blood and screams and dread. The man
singlehandedly changed American cinema during a scene we all saw coming.
All the President’s
Men (1976)
After all the research and interviews and covert parking
garage meetings, Washington Post reporters Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward
finally convince their Executive Editor, Ben Bradlee, that they have proof to
back their story of Watergate. They’re going to blow the whole thing wide open,
and ultimately help force the resignation of President Nixon. In one of the
best, most telling shots in film history, the film ends with the camera slowly
panning into Woodward and Bernstein typing their story furiously in the
background, as Nixon, on TV, is inaugurated as President in the foreground.
Malcolm X (1992)
One of the things that makes Malcolm X as endearing as it is, is the fact that the film doesn’t
end with the death of its main subject. Instead, Spike Lee ingeniously has
actor and Civil Rights activist, Ossie Davis, orate the eulogy he gave at X’s
funeral, while Lee fills the frame with archive footage of the real Malcolm X.
It’s the perfect swan song for an epic masterpiece. Easily one of the smartest
choices of Lee’s career.
Schindler’s List
(1993)
Similar to Malcolm X,
Steven Spielberg wisely chose to end his film not with Oscar Schindler basking
in the glory of all the good he’d done, but rather with a stirring sequence of
truth. Gracefully switching to color, we watch as the real life Jewish people
Schindler saved, accompanied by the actor who portrayed them in the movie,
gently place rocks on Schindler’s grave. That’s unlike anything I’ve seen before or since.
Apollo 13 (1995)
There’s something so emotional about watching Jim Lovell and
Co. silently fall back into orbit. Their module dangles in the air, slowly
parachuting to the ocean, Ed Harris’ Gene Kranz melts in his chair, cries, and
we all let out a sigh a relief we knew was coming.
Minutes earlier, Kranz told his superior that, “I believe
this is going to be our finest hour.” And he was damn right.
Monster (2003)
Often inaccurately cited as the first female serial killer,
I knew the demise of Aileen Wuornos long before I stepped into Patty Jenkins’
unrelenting film. I had seen Nick Broomfield’s unflinching documentary, Aileen Wuornos: The Selling of a Serial
Killer, and had followed the case closely to see if Wuornos would get an 11th
hour stay of execution. Now, in knowing how the film would end, did that make
it any less gut wrenching? Not in the slightest.
Downfall (2004)
Is it possible to make a beyond-engrossing film about the
final days of Adolf Hitler’s life? With Bruno Ganz fearlessly playing the lead,
you bet your ass. Perhaps the many many many many internet parodies would
agree.
Zodiac (2007)
Since the publication of his book that started it all,
author Robert Graysmith has released other tell-alls in which he confidently
asserts that Arthur Leigh Allen was indeed the Zodiac killer. David Fincher
wisely chose to end his film with the same mentality that most people still
have: we’ll never really know who
tormented the San Francisco bay area for all those years. An intelligent, and
no less eerie, end to a story that may very well never find its conclusion.
'Twas then when the
Hurdy Gurdy Man Came singing songs of love.
Milk (2008)
Rob Epstein’s Oscar-winning film, The Times of Harvey Milk,
is one of the finest documentaries I’ve ever seen. Period.
I was well aware that Gus Van Sant’s film wouldn’t end
without Sean Penn meeting his demise at the hands of an enraged Josh Brolin. (I
wasn’t aware, however, that Van Sant would begin
his film by verbally announcing this.) But that didn’t matter. Milk is a wholly courageous movie about
a wholly courageous man. Van Sant did the story justice, despite the fact that
we all knew how it was going to go down.
Public Enemies
(2009)
Anyone with moderate interest in historical American crime
knows that John Dillinger met his maker at the hands of the FBI, courtesy of
the woman in red (who was actually wearing orange, but anyway).
But thanks to Johnny Depp’s accurate portrayal, guided by
Michael Mann’s ever-so-reliable direction, the life and death of Dillinger is
never, for a second, anything else than evocative. Bye bye, Blackbird.
There are many more
films worthy to make this list, feel free to tell me some of your favorites!
I've seen all but Downfall but this is a damn good list.
ReplyDeleteI would've added A Night to Remember, which I saw recently and loved. I mean, yeah, it basically covers the same territory as Titanic, but it doesn't sugarcoat the details at all.
Thanks! I haven't seen A Night to Remember, but have heard nothing by good things. Glad to hear it leaves the gloss at the door.
DeleteI really have to see Malcolm X. I love films whose endings one knows and is still surprised by it. Like I love Titanic and it kills me.
ReplyDeleteMy favourite from this list has to be Bonnie and Clyde just because it was so shocking still. And I cried bucket loads in Milk.
Of course one of my favourite endings of all time is Marie Antoinette because it doesn't actually show the beheading but you know it's there in the horizon. It's the fact that nothing is shown is what gets me.
Also though it isn't a true story, Moulin Rouge! starts with Ewan McGregor's character talking about how the woman he loves is dead and then we see their whole romance and it still is so awful and sad at the end.
I think it takes a great skill to still surprise someone with an ending that was bound to happen.
Yeah, I completely agree with your final sentence - if you can be surprised by a film whose ending you're aware of, then that definitely speaks volumes for the movie.
DeleteMarie Antoinette is a great choice, for exactly the reason you mentioned!
I haven't watched Public Enemies, but I've seen all the others and those are all good picks, especially Schindler's List. I'm not sure how many people know the Zodiac Killer story, though. I saw a lot of comments from disappointed viewers at the time the movie came to DVD because they were not expecting an open ended movie.
ReplyDeleteThanks man, glad you dig the list.
DeleteThese youngins, Chip, we gotta teach 'em about these psychopathic serial killers.
But really, I love that people were upset that Fincher ended the story accurately, and not with some hammed-up Hollywood version (like, uh... Dirty Harry).
I think I would put Bonnie and Clyde and Downfall in my top 15.
ReplyDeleteAll of these are such good movies, who cares if you already know the story, there's much more to the craft than an ending. Every viewer should know that
Couldn't agree more, brother man. Sadly, a lot of viewers don't see it that way. Shame.
DeleteThe end to Schindler's List is fantastic - it brings this whole new dimension to the movie that isn't used to emotionally manipulate, but you see the true worth of the true story. After three hours of the grittiest, bleakest stuff, it ends on this poignant, bittersweet note. I absolutely adore it.
ReplyDeleteYep, couldn't agree more. The first time I saw the film, I had no idea what was happening, but when Ben Kingsley walked into frame, it all clicked. Perfect way to end a perfect film.
DeleteThat's kind of a ridiculous argument on their part. It's all about the story and how it's presented. As long as it's told well, it shouldn't matter as much that we know the end.
ReplyDeleteAwesome list, BTW. Happy to see Bonnie & Clyde included. Saw that for the first time this summer, and it blew me away.
Yeah, I am in complete agreement with you. It's a very flimsy argument, at best. But oh well.
DeleteGlad you dig Bonnie and Clyde, that one has really stood the test of time.
lots of great ones here.
ReplyDeleteThanks!
DeleteIf you couldn't watch a film you knew the ending to, you'd never be able to watch *any* film more than once, surely. I feel terribly sorry for people like that. Or is it terrible contempt? I don't know.
ReplyDeleteAs for Titanic, knowing the "ending" was a problem for me, but that was because I was sick of the romantic bullshit and couldn't wait for it to get to the fucking iceberg...
Your first paragraph pretty much sums up my thoughts on the subject perfectly. It's such a shoddy argument. (sigh), oh well.
DeleteAs for your Titanic comment: Bring on the BERG!!
Yep. Can't argue with any of these. All the President's Men is especially true for me. It was so engrossing that I was worried Woodward and Bernstein would be murdered for prying into the conspiracy. I knew that didn't happen, but it was just so nerve-racking. Nice list man.
ReplyDeleteThanks dude. Glad you're an All the President's Men fan, that movie has and will always stand the test of time. A truly remarkable film.
DeleteGreat lists! Sometimes it even happens in the movies that are original - we know the ending within first few moments of American Beauty.
ReplyDeleteIt never really ruins things for me as I don't even mind spoilers, in Zodiac's case though it was very frustrating not to know for sute. Fincher could only do this like this, so it's not really a flaw in the movie other than it annoys me not to know who Zodiac was.
Thanks! I think it annoys a whole shit load of people to not really know who the Zodiac is. But that is kind of the crux of the whole thing: It is one, if not the, most infamous unsolved case in American crime. Crazy shit.
DeleteWonderful list! I especially like Milk and Zodiac being on here. I thought of Miracle when I read this list. The hockey movie, even though I knew they won, I still was on the edge of my seat during it. It's not the best movie out there, but I enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteThanks! Ah, I LOVE Miracle, which is still so odd to me, because the tired sports biopic is definitely NOT my kind of film. Had I remembered that one, I definitely would've included it here. Great choice, and thanks for reading/commenting!
DeleteGreat idea for a list and you list some great ones here. I actually don't mind seeing films I already know the ending to, I mean I think if done well it could still be very gripping and emotionally fulfilling. Schindler's List is one of those films, and though I knew the ending of ARGO I didn't read up too much details about it so the film was still quite tense all around.
ReplyDeleteYep, that's exactly the point I was hoping to get at - even if you know how the real story went down, there's no reason the film itself can't be engrossing. Thanks for the comment, Ruth!
DeleteGreat list! Sadly I've only seen 3 of these movies, but they were great ones. I'm glad you loved the closing shot of All the President's Men as much as I did. Terrific film! Milk and Schindler's List were wonderful, too.
ReplyDeleteThanks! That shot from President's Men is just epic, isn't it? So much going on there. In a lot of ways, they simple do not make 'em like they used to.
DeleteI still haven't seen Bonnie and Clyde, I feel ashamed.
ReplyDeleteAs for the others, great picks. Monster is a great film.
Oh Bonnie and Clyde is one of those movies that is just as good (if not better) than everything you've heard. It lives up to the hype. Glad you like the picks!
DeleteSuch a great idea for a list, Alex! So many classic movies I haven't seen and now want to watch more than ever... Thanks for giving away all their endings... JK! If you are hooked by a good storyline, knowing the resolution shouldn't make it any less enjoyable. Old man Ralph Waldo Emerson said it best, “Life is a journey, not a destination.”
ReplyDeleteThanks! I can't recommend all of these flicks highly enough, even if you already know their endings!
DeleteNice Emerson quote, very fitting indeed.
I'm glad that I'm not an American 'case I don't know the ending of Malcolm X or Monster or Zodiac or Milk or Public Enemies (I might have heard something once about this one, though).
ReplyDeleteThat IS good that you don't know those endings. I highly recommend all of those films.
DeleteMost, if not all, of these films are Hollywood working its myth-making magic. Not one of these "stories" tells the real truth. Watch them again after you've done serious research into alternative historical perspectives. If you can stomach it.
ReplyDeleteYep, totally agree. Truth is often stranger (and scarier) than fiction.
DeleteAh! Kindred spirits! Thanks, Alex.
ReplyDeleteCordially,
babette