With the exception of film, there is little that I love more
than the art of boxing. I’m not a sports guy (at all), but when it comes to the
sweet science of boxing, I am in complete awe. It’s a sport I’ve witnessed,
practiced and cherished with equal levels of fascination. There’s something
about the calculation that goes into the whole thing that I find unique and
interesting.
There is, however, a catch to being such a fan of the sport:
I am virtually unable to enjoy any boxing film that gets the boxing scenes
wrong. One of the best, most recent examples of this is David O. Russell’s The Fighter. Good movie, horribly
inauthentic boxing scenes. Micky Ward was such a unique, driven fighter, and
the film portraying him in no way capitalized on that.
Oh well. Just keep in mind that for the purposes of this
post, I am only focusing on the boxing. Here are the ones that got it right,
pound for pound.
This is a bit of a cheat, because, quite frankly, the boxing
in all the Rocky films is horrible and completely counterfeit. With all that in
mind, it still does not take away from the baddassness of watching a 60-year-old
Sylvester Stallone beat down (and get beat up) by an in-his-prime Antonio
Tarver. Their final showdown is fun, brutal, and nostalgic in all the best
ways. Sure, some serious boxing Hollywood liberties are being taken here
(Lesson 1: If your glove touches the mat, then it’s considered a knockdown),
but damn if it ain’t great to see The Rock give it one final go.
7. Cinderella Man
I’m far from the biggest fan of Ron Howard’s James Braddock biopic,
but Russell Crowe’s obvious dedication makes for some pretty believable bouts.
It’s a shame that Howard felt the need to drown out the fighting scenes in
obnoxious sepia, and that his go-to effect is slow motion, the killer of all boxing
scenes, but all in all, Howard and Co. did a fine job highlighting the ancient
styles of Depression-era boxing.
6. The Boxer
Daniel Day-Lewis hardly has any boxing scenes to fully flex
his commitment in The Boxer, but needless to say, his method acting shines through here in
the best way possible. Really, The Boxer
only contains one notable boxing sequence, and it is one of such unique humility
and compassion, you’ll be damned to find two guys pounding on each other as
moving as it is here. The Jim Sheridan/Daniel Day-Lewis collaboration is most
often remembered for My Left Foot and
In the Name of the Father, but The Boxer is a fine addition to the work
these two men did together.
5. The Hurricane
Norman Jewison’s The
Hurricane contains Denzel Washington’s best, most devoted performance
(second only to Malcolm X, of course),
which is made clear the second you see him step in the ring. At the time of shooting,
Denzel was 44-years-old, but he looks as young as the real life character he’s
portraying. This isn’t done with digital effects, mind you, but rather
steadfast dedication from an actor at the top of his game.
Jewison made the ballsy decision to shoot all of the boxing
scenes in gorgeous black a white (an ode to Raging
Bull, as he points out in his commentary), and that, mixed with Christopher
Young’s marvelous stringed music, and, of course, the actor himself, makes for
some of the best boxing ever put on screen.
Also, I’d be remiss if I didn’t
make specific mention of how flawlessly Denzel incorporates Rubin Hurricane
Carter’s very specific style of fighting into his performance. Carter boxed
like a karate kid, blocking punches with his forearms and bobbing and weaving infinitely
more than any of his challengers. Breathtaking to watch on screen.
4. Million Dollar Baby
Clint Eastwood’s dark, moody, melodramatic work of art has
several things going for it, namely its many scenes of authentic-as-all-hell
boxing. With the exception of what happens at the end of the final match, there’s
nothing that occurs inside the ring during Million
Dollar Baby that doesn’t occur frequently inside the ring in real life.
Popping the nose back into place, cheap shots when the ref isn’t looking –
everything Eastwood captured is as real as it gets.
Two things to note. First, in typical Eastwood fashion, the
boxing scenes were not rehearsed or storyboarded, they were improvised on the
day they were shot. Two: I love the lengths at which Eastwood and Paul Haggis’ script go to explaining the art of boxing. Not many films tell you (accurately) how to
hit a speed bag. Those lessons here help to make the film as credible as it is.
3. Raging Bull
We’re nearing the end and you may have noticed something:
all of the films I’m highlighting are relatively new. There’s no The Harder They Fall, no Somebody Up There Likes Me, no Champion – and that’s for good reason.
When you talk about the authenticity of boxing in film, there is before Raging Bull, and after Raging Bull. Before Martin Scorsese made
his masterpiece, every boxing scene in every movie was utter crap. The actors
never hit each other, the sound effects were seriously overblown… it just didn’t
work. Then Scorsese came along and did two things that changed the game: he did
whatever the hell he wanted, and he never left the ring.
The fighting scenes in Raging
Bull are 100 percent style, which should in no way work. Scorsese implored
slow motion, sped-up motion, far too much blood, and, hell, he even changed the
damn size of the ring to fit whatever vision he had. But he did it without
leaving the ring. I cannot think of a single film other than Raging Bull in which, during the boxing
scenes, the camera never steps outside of the ring. Yes, once Jake La Motta and
his brother Joey have their disastrous falling out, Scorsese cross-cuts Jake’s
most brutal fight with Joey’s reaction watching it from home, but the point is
that Raging Bull broke the rules and
changed the game. It’s a film that will be remembered as long as there are
films.
2. When We Were Kings
Leon Gast’s remarkable, Oscar-winning documentary chronicles
the trials and tribulations behind the most famous boxing match of all time,
The Rumble in the Jungle. Everyone from Spike Lee to Norman Mailer to George
Plimpton are interviewed concerning Muhammad Ali’s revelatory knockout of
George Foreman in Zaire.
What balls it takes to not only step in the ring with a
bigger, stronger and more lethal fighter than you, but to actually let him beat the holy hell out of you
for seven and a half rounds. Ali had guts, sure, but more importantly to this
bout, he had brains. No one (including Ali’s trainer) knew what Ali was doing,
but damn if the risk didn’t pay off. When
We Were Kings is essential for anyone who enjoys films and/or loves boxing.
If you’re a fan of both, you’ll be in heaven.
1. Ali
Funny that I find the narrative depiction of a fight to be
more enthralling than the actual depiction
of the same fight, but hey, sometimes art imitates life better than life
itself. Look, I know Michael Mann’s biopic has its fair share of detractors,
but I simply love everything about this film, and if we’re only focusing on the
fighting, then it is a goddamn masterpiece.
Putting expert cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki to the test
in ways he hadn’t been before, the boxing in Ali is shot using a multitude of methods. Gorgeous widescreen,
gritty handheld, sparsely (but effectively) implored slow motion – everything about
the style of the boxing scenes here works. But that’s just the look, there’s
certainly a lot more going on here, most notably Will Smith’s epic incarnation
of one (if not the) most famous athletes of all time. Smith put on the pounds,
he packed the attitude, and he nailed Ali’s unique style of fighting.
Everything about his performance works.
While I love the many fight scenes in Ali, specific respect must be paid to Mann’s retelling of The
Rumble in the Jungle, in which he practically shows the Ali/Foreman bout in
real time. I’ve studied that real life fight. It’s something I’ve watched over
and over and over (it can easily be found on YouTube, like here for instance),
and watching the real fight back-to-back with Mann’s version of it is clear
evidence of a guy doing his homework. Every punch, every sidestep, every grimaced
face – Mann carried it through with accuracy, effect, and respect. For a boxing
fan, there’s simply nothing better.
Great list! Raging Bull was great and I especially loved his last fight with Sugar Ray- the way it was shot was brilliant. As for style and execution, I didn't think it was that good- you could see continuity problems with blood spatters and in some points it was rather clear they weren't actually hitting each other. Maybe I am just very picky :P
ReplyDeleteHa maybe! But honestly... yeah, the continuity errors are there but the passion, um, rage, seriously outweighs all of that stuff. For me, at least.
DeleteYes! Another Ali fan! I'm still surprised by how few people seem to really like this film. I agree with you about the Foreman/Ali fight at the end, but the showdown that works best for me is the original match with Sonny Liston. Mann takes his time and really gives us an up-close look into Ali's thought process, and Will Smith totally sells it. I was gripped from the start because of that fight (and the great opening sequence with Sam Cooke), and it's held up really well on repeated viewings.
ReplyDeleteOh that first Linston fight is incredible. I especially love how Mann shows Ali's footwork once that pepper spray concoction starts to wear off. Great great scenes. Glad you're such a fan of Ali! It needs more supporters.
DeleteThat is a great list. I have no complaints here. My favorite fight in the Rocky movies is in Rocky IV where he gets that punch on Drago and cuts him. I was like "oh shit!" And Rocky starts to wail on him as it follows this nice break where Duke tells him, "You cut him! You see! He's not a machine! He's a man!"
ReplyDeleteOh that is a great great scene. Fuckin' iconic Rocky right there.
DeleteI'll probably be the apologist on behalf of CINDERELLA MAN, although I'd admit I like it less for its boxing than for its general story. I always feel that that was one given significantly less credit than it deserved back in 2005.
ReplyDeleteTo be fair, it isn't that bad, actually, it isn't really bad at all, I just can never seem to fully get into it, you know? Either way, fight scenes are pretty legit. Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteThat is an outstanding list, I really love boxing scenes in movies, especially in Raging bull and Million Dollar Baby. I really need to see Ali some time!
ReplyDeleteThanks!! If you like boxing scenes then Ali is a MUST. Excellent fighting in thy flick.
DeleteAnd by thy I mean that. Goddamn autocorrect.
DeleteSo what do you think of the Pacquiao fight and the decision? Did you see it? I didn't, but I'm wondering if it really appeared to be as one-sided as I have been hearing.
ReplyDeleteThat decision was as absurd as you've heard. It really is a shame, because boxing is by far my favorite sport... but decisions like that make the rigged argument that much easier to make. Mark my words, Pacquiao will go for the kill in the rematch. Every punch will be a knockout.
DeleteGreat list, man. I like that you included Rocky Balboa on here. I loved the HBO presentation of that fight -- it was cool that they were able to piggyback off a real event. Probably the best fight in the whole series, especially when you factor in the nostalgia.
ReplyDeleteOh hell yeah, I definitely agree that that fight is the best in the series. I love that he shot it in blown out HD to give it that HBO look. Great great fight scene.
Delete"First, in typical Eastwood fashion, the boxing scenes were not rehearsed or storyboarded, they were improvised on the day they were shot." Is that right? That makes sense given Eastwood - like you point out - but I didn't know it. Interesting. Definitely aided that raw feeling.
ReplyDeleteI also like that you have "The Boxer" here. Never felt that one got enough attention.
Yeah, they talked about that non rehearsal on the special features for the movie. I'm sure the boxing scenes were loosely scripted, like, "Maggie knocks several boxers out in a row in the first round," but the moves and the mechanics of the fights were thought up the day off, which is fuckin' nuts.
DeleteI love The Boxer. Only wish it had more boxing it in. But definitely a great movie.