But there’s a flip side. The inverse to his trademark
intensity is his genuine tenderness. He can play mean and he can play earnest,
as good as any of them.
Because today is Harris’ 62nd birthday, I thought
it would be appropriate to list my Top 10 favorite scenes of his career. From
brooding to sensitive, here’s where Harris has been at his finest.
10. The Firm – “We’ll probably see each other again.”
10. The Firm – “We’ll probably see each other again.”
There’s something so cool and eerie about the moment we meet
Harris in The Firm. Bald-headed and
fitted in a shitty suit, he strolls into a diner, sits across from Tom Cruise,
and slowly begins to harass Cruise’s character. The words he uses, the slight
smirks he shines, the way he eats saltines in one bite – it’s all so off
putting. Who is he? Cop? Competing lawyer? Hit man? We have no idea, but damn
if we aren’t counting the minutes until he comes back.
9. The Hours – “Just wait ‘til I die, then you’ll have
to think of yourself.”
Harris is only in two scenes of The Hours, but damn if he doesn’t leave his mark. As a bitter man
slowly dying of AIDS, his two moments with Meryl Streep mark some of the most
gut wrenching work of his career. I suppose I’m more drawn to their first encounter
together, in which Harris’ character lambasts Streep for her constant support.
In one moment, he threateningly asks her what she’s going to do with herself once he’s dead.
It’s a simple, heartbreaking scene of a life lost.
8. A History of
Violence – “Put the popgun down,
come over and talk to us.”
After Philadelphia thug Carl Fogarty has delicately harassed
poor Tom Stall and his family, Fogarty finally decides to bring things to a
head by kidnapping Tom’s son and showing up at the Stall house. Watching Harris
here, scar faced and impossibly calm, you can’t help but know that shit is
about to get very bad very quickly. Which… it does.
(Note: The clip below contains spoilers.)
7. The Truman Show – “Say
something, goddamnit! You’re on television!”
Once Harris’ Christof is finally face to face (well… kind
of) with his lifelong subject, Truman, we are privy to a unique scene in which
Harris flexes fatherly warmth, avert narcissism, and vengeful pride all in the
span of one gentle monologue. I mean, really, what is Christof expecting of
Truman here? That he’s just going to turn around and continue with the show
like normal? This moment is a hopeless, last ditch effort for Christof to
attain all he’s worked for, and it is devastating to watch.
6. Glengarry Glen
Ross – “FUCK THE MACHINE!”
The David Mamet-penned Glengarry
Glen Ross is as fine an exercise in screenwriting as any film made before
or since. The movie is filled with moments of heated exchanges, none more jaw
dropping than the scene in which Harris’ Dave Moss attempts (and fails
miserably) at attacking Al Pacino’s Ricky Roma. Moss’ futile attempts to
unleash his pent up aggression results in him walking away with his head down
in shame, dragging his feet across the shitty office floor. He tries to let out
one final Fuck You, but by then, the battle has been lost.
5. Pollock – “I’m not
the phony, you’re the phony.”
There are few scenes in Harris’ incredible film, Pollock, that hit harder than the moment
in which Pollock, himself a helpless alcoholic, has his first drink in two
years. His initial enjoyment in reveling in the drink, followed soon by a
violent outburst, is some of the most powerful acting Harris has ever done.
Watching him take two huge pulls of liquor, then slither around a dinner party,
plotting his move – Christ, it’s just unbearable.
4. Pollock – Inspiration
Takes Hold
No matter your preferred method of art, there’s nothing more
terrifying than an empty canvas staring back at you. I’ve seen many movies that
depict that EUREKA moment of an artist finally getting their inspiration, but
I’m hard pressed to think of one more accomplished than this.
There’s Pollock, staring helplessly at a giant canvas that
is to act as a mural for New York socialite Peggy Guggenheim. He stares and
smokes and stares and smokes. Nothing. Then… BAM.
There are three masterful things at work here: Ed Harris’
flawless paint strokes, Jeff Beal’s lyrical score, and Lisa Rinzler’s seamless
camera. A bravado piece of filmmaking.
3a. Apollo 13 – “I believe
this is going to be our finest hour.”
A bit of a cheat here, but for me, these two scenes from Apollo 13 are completely inseparable.
Soon before the astronauts attempt to make it back Earth-side, Flight Director
Gene Kranz overhears his superiors talk about the fatal disaster that may
occur. The camera cuts left, Harris turns to frame and delivers a line of utter
conviction.
Tom Hanks’ “Houston, we have a problem,” always gets more play, but Harris’ delivery here deserves just as much credit.
Tom Hanks’ “Houston, we have a problem,” always gets more play, but Harris’ delivery here deserves just as much credit.
3b. Apollo 13 –
Sinking Tears
Once Jim Lovell and his two cohorts are back in Earth’s
atmosphere, Harris let’s out a perfectly restrained sigh of relief as everyone
around him celebrates in ecstatic jubilation. He slowly sinks into his chair, relieved
to no end. After a brief moment, he stands up and wipes tears from his eyes
while shaking the hands of those around him. If that’s not acting, then I don’t
know what is.
2. Glengarry Glen
Ross – “Because you listened.”
After being told off by Alec Baldwin’s crass Blake, Harris’
Dave Moss is pissed. Pissed and looking to get even. After some plotting, Moss
spends several minutes verbally setting up Alan Arkin’s sorrowful George. Moss
tells anecdote after anecdote, before finally getting to the point: he
wants George to break into their office, steal the hot new real estate leads,
and sell them to a competitor. George is stunned, and refuses to cooperate.
Moss threatens blackmail, and George wonders why. Why him? Why now?
Why? Because he listened.
(Note: I couldn’t find a clip of the scene in question, so
below is part of Moss’ setup.)
1. The Abyss – “SHE
WANTS TO LIVE!”
One of the single best-acted scenes I have ever witnessed
takes place as Ed Harris is trying to bring his wife back to life in James
Cameron’s The Abyss. After forcing
herself to drown so that Harris could swim them back to their submarine, Harris
and his team attempt CPR, the use of a defibrillator, CPR, defibrillator,
before giving up. No pulse.
But fuck that.
Harris has no interest in quitting, and what follows is a
scene of such ferocious power, that it draws comparison to De Niro’s fight with
a jailhouse concrete wall in Raging Bull.
After another minute or so of mouth-to-mouth, Harris resorts to slapping her
around and screaming, “Fight!” over and over until his voice goes hoarse. This
moment, and what happens as a result of it, never fails to bring tears to my
eyes.
Anyone with a remote interest in the acting art form –
whether as a spectator or executor – needs to watch and study this scene. This
is how it is done.
I honestly think he should have won for those two scenes in The Hours. (But then again, the race that year was pretty tight.)
ReplyDeleteYeah that is a damn tight year indeed. I could go for Harris, Walken, Newman or Cooper for the win. Great performances all around.
DeleteThat scene in The Abyss is my favorite. That's why Ed Harris rocks.
ReplyDeleteYeah man, no doubt. Scene rocks me to the core.
DeleteNice Ed Harris write-ups!
ReplyDeleteLove the scenes in Glengarry Glenross and The Abyss. Great movies.
Thanks man! He's so damn good in both of those flicks. Flawless really.
DeleteAs I was reading and scrolling down I was wondering if the "If you see me coming, you better run, because I am gonna lay you the fuck down" scene in Gone Baby Gone was going to make the cut.
ReplyDeleteHarris has been so powerful in so many movies, but this could almost have been his peak for me. Few actors sell intense conviction like Harris does.
The film itself must be one of the most perenially underrated, you don't hear much about it, I have it marginally behind The Town and just ahead of Argo in terms of Affleck's work as a director, and all three were top five or ten for their year in my opinion.
That scene was, swear to God, number 11 on the list. I LOVE Gone Baby Gone and his performance in it. I'm a huge fan of Affleck's directorial work. If I had to rate the three... I dunno, that's tough. I think Argo is his most mature, Gone Baby Gone is his most accomplished, and The Town is his most entertaining. Tough to pick a favorite, love them all.
DeleteThanks so much for commenting!
Great post! I'm adding The Abyss and Pollack to my Watchlist. I also need to see Glen Glengarry Ross. I saw and liked another film, titled Homicide, written by Mamet.
ReplyDeleteThanks! Okay, take it from me, you would love Pollock. I'm usually nervous in asserting for certain what people will and won't like, but you'll like that one.
DeleteHomicide is fantastic; I'm a huge admirer of Mamet's. Glengarry is, inarguably, his best script to date. It just sings with venom.
Came in here to make sure The Truman Show was mentioned. Good to see you have it covered.
ReplyDeleteOf course man, he's perfect there.
DeleteThis is a great list man. Pollock and The Abyss have been on my watchlist for years, so I really should watch them soon.
ReplyDeleteThanks dude. Harris makes Pollock good for so many reasons. It's one of the best acting performances I've ever seen a director direct himself in. Very intense.
DeleteThe Abyss, in my opinion, is James Cameron's best film. It isn't his best action flick, but his best overall film.
Great list, one of my absolute favorite character actors out there. Really wanted that scene in the Rock with him confronting the mercenaries in his group. It's not saying much but his General Hummel is the best acting job in any Bay film. The gag reel should also be considered as that is one of the best examples of how intense the guy is, off screen too. Dunno if you've seen it but it is pure Ed, intense and scary:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYN6t5xt0ps
How does anyone on the crew not want to give it their best with that man acting, and he took the role just for a pay-check...
Oh man, whenever I'm feeling down, I watch those bloopers to give myself a boost. Fucking hilarious.
Delete"I don't know what you mean 'In the light,' SIR!" "From the window SIR!?" "GODDAAAAMIT! FUCK!"
Priceless Ed. And I agree, best performance from a Michael Bay film, no question.
God I love him in The Hours (then again I love everyone and everything in The Hours). Also Truman Show. Have to rewatch Glengarry Glen Ross.
ReplyDeleteGreat flicks all around right there. I could watch Glengarry on repeat.
DeleteThe Abyss! Yes! Alex, nice job picking that scene from a movie that often gets forgotten. Harris is one of the most consistent actors out there, and his performances in Apollo 13 and The Truman Show are great examples. Cool list.
ReplyDeleteThanks man! Glad you're an Abyss fan, great movie, great scene. I agree, Harris is consistent as all hell.
DeleteNo THE ROCK? That was the first HARRIS film I saw,and loved his performance in it.Glengarry Glen Ross has been talked so often in the blogsphere,I don't know why I still haven't seen it yet.
ReplyDeleteOh man, I love him in The Rock, but the other scenes I mentioned take precedence for me. Seriously cannot recommend GGR highly enough. A ferocious work of art.
DeleteThe problem with The Abyss resuscitation scene is it just went on for too long. I remember sitting in the theater wondering when it would finally be over.
ReplyDeleteHmm, that's an interesting point. I never saw this film in the theater, but I can definitely see the length of this scene being a little awkward while watching it in a large, dark room with a bunch of strangers.
DeleteOh my God I was just googling why he was bald in The Firm (about to watch that) because I was curious of that (cause I'm so shallow) and your post showed up and I'm like HOW DID I MISS THIS?!! Apparently I haven't found your awesome blog yet when you published this
ReplyDeleteI'm going through all of his films because I wanna write something like your In Character except if I manage, I wanna write about everything there is out there with him I can watch. I already saw more than half of his resume, just last Friday I saw Sweet Dreams which I have to say is his best work from what I've seen. It's just insane what he does there. I haven't seen Pollock fully yet, I started it but it was so damn heavy I decided not to watch that on Monday, I cannot wait to finish this. I did see that painting scene and it was amazing.
And he should have won for that crying scene in Apollo 13. Yes Spacey was great that year but this is just such an honest moment. And it truly is amazing how he can play bad guys and such sweet guys at the same level of convincing.
So happy you found this post! I hadn't even heard of Sweet Dreams until my mom told me about it a year and a half ago. Harris is so damn good in that movie. Makes me want to watch it again actually.
DeleteHis nuance in that Apollo 13 scene is remarkable.
I really wanna see Pollock tonight, hopefully I will make it through the entire film this time. I heard he wants to direct another movie next spring so yey! And hopefully his part in Aronofsky's latest is gonna be good.
DeleteYou've gotta check out his scenes in Westworld. It's just the coolest thing ever.
I really do need to crush out Westworld. I've heard nothing but great things.
DeletePollock is still my favorite Harris performance. Such intensity there.
He was just incredible in Pollock, wow that scene where he has his first drink in 2 years was really amazing but my favorite was the extension of opening scene where he just looks at his wife and he looks so haunted. Did you see Harris' reaction when Marcia won the Oscar? He almost killed her with his glassed :D
DeleteYES! I love that hug and kiss. He is so so surprised. Kate Hudson was a lock that year. I love Harden and Harris' stunned reaction.
Delete